Follow
Share
Find Care & Housing
No. Certainly not.
My parents didn't have services, nor did my brother, nor will I. We all have had/have opted for simple cremation and disposal of ashes.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report

If it's you , you are asking for absolutely not. If you don't want one, don't let anyone guilt you.

If it's for someone else, I believe you should respect the persons wishes, if it doesn't cost you money and within reason. If the person wishes for a big elaborate funeral, they should figure out how it will be paid for , way before death.

That the way I feel anyways
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Anxietynacy
Report

Are you asking for yourself or if you have to have a funeral for a loved one?

If you don't want them to have one for you when you pass away - I would just make your wishes clear to the loved one or Executor of your estate. They will have to do something - be it bury or cremate - and you can talk about all of that as well. But you can absolutely tell them that you don't wish to have a funeral.

As far as the other side of the question - if you are asking if you have to have one for a loved one - nope (in most cases). Unless they have PREPAID for an entire funeral AND left specific requirements for said funeral - in which case you probably have to HAVE it but that doesn't mean you have to tell anyone else about it - so you don't have to go through the process of having an actual funeral with receiving line and well wishes.

My FIL was in the middle. He wanted a "state" funeral. He had it all planned out, choirs, special speakers, special music, massive amounts of flowers, the most ornate coffin. You could tell he had envisioned it as if he would be there. (my FIL had NPD).

BUT...he never paid a penny to make those dreams come true. And frankly he didn't leave enough in his life insurance policy to cover even a third of what he wanted.

So, instead we did what WE wanted to do. Which was to cremate him and have no service.

In my opinion, funerals are for the living. And MANY MANY of the living are getting to the point where they don't want to go to funerals anymore if they can help it.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to BlueEyedGirl94
Report

You don’t “have” to do much of anything. If it brings you peace to skip having a funeral, do that
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Daughterof1930
Report

NO, you do what you want if you want.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to funkygrandma59
Report

This is as personal as dying.
If you are asking for yourself...YOU do what YOU want.
The best thing to do if possible is to pre plan and pre pay your funeral.
That way it is all done the way you want it done.
There is nothing that says you HAVE to have a "Wake", a Visitation, a funeral or a burial.
If you have everything pre planned the funeral home can be called and they will come and pick you up and begin to carry out your wishes.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Grandma1954
Report

My DH and I are being cremated. I want no viewing or service. If my girls feel they want a memorial service, thats up to them. I told them to just go for a nice dinner.

I think COVID taught us that funerals are not really needed.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report

Ugh; funerals. That was the topic at a dinner party my husband and I went to a couple years ago. I was the only one at the table who said I do not want a funeral, I do not want a memorial service, I do not want a celebration of life party, I do not want a gravesite for anyone to visit. I want to pop off into the ozone and be everywhere and nowhere. I will plan and pay for that in advance.

Although no one came right out and said it, it was implied that I am selfish for denying my loved ones the chance to mourn me and say goodbye; that “funerals are for the living”. I reject that. But I did tell my daughter that if at my death she feels the need, she can put together one of those online memorial sites where an obituary is posted and people add their farewells. If she doesn’t, it’s certainly not going to bother me up there in the ozone!
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Peasuep
Report
swmckeown76 Dec 21, 2024
Tha'ts fine for you, especially if you're not religious. In my faith (Anglican), we're like Catholics in this regard. A body must be placed in a casket and buried in a funeral plot or if cremated, the urn must be buried in a funeral plot, placed in a niche in a columbarium/mausoleum, or buried in a memorisl garden with a marker (our parish has one). My late husband wanted burial, so I purchased a funeral plot and casket and prepaid for everything else about 15 months before he died. I had obituaries in three newspapers and had written his up and ready to go when he entered hospice care. Visitation can occur in a funeral home or in the church's parish hall the day before or prior to the Requiem Eucharist. Depending on the priest, he/she might allow family members to serve as lectors and lead the Prayers of the People, but probably not as chalice bearers during the celebration of the Eucharist. I asked my late husband's sisters and one of my sisters to serve as lectors at his Requiem Eucharist. I also had this live-streamed and several people from his high school and college (we lived over 400 miles from there) were able to watch the live stream. (Although not required, the Tech Services Ministry that does this has a limited budget and I donated some $$$ to them for this service.) His long-term care center typically sends a few people to attend as well. They also keep a picture of the deceased and a copy of her/his obituary on display for a few days. They asked me if I wanted his clothing back. I knew a number of the residents were mostly dependent on Medicaid to pay for their long-term care (my late husband was private-pay) and their personal allowance is pretty skimpy. So I said they should give his clothes to someone who could use them.
(0)
Report
No, and let it be known that I am tired of going to them. There've been so many, and traveling to a funeral is difficult. I loved an online Gathering that my friend's family held after she passed! We all signed into it from our own computers and shared stories of what our friend had meant to us in our lives. Compared to the sadness, the coffin being wheeled out, the drooping flowers, and devastated wives, husbands and family of the deceased at a traditional funeral, the Gathering was uplifting. It was even fun to hear all the others' stories of our dear departed friend.

I'm not having a funeral other than military commitment honors when I join my husband in a national cemetery.

NOT having a funeral seems most considerate of others.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Fawnby
Report
Hedgie Sep 25, 2024
Not sure which national cemetery you will be using, but I just had my mother interred at Arlington National Cemetry (Dad was US Navy in WWII and was interred in the Columbarium at Arlington 30 years ago.)

To say the service was short would be an understatement -- as the Spouse, Mom got a 5 minute service (after waiting 10 months to be interred). I don't know if all Veteran cemetaries have the same restrictions.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
Nope, and I don't want one, either.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Tiredniece23
Report

Absolutely NOT.
In your will or trust make it clear that you want NO SERVICES or end of life gatherings.
No one in my family had services. I don't intend to and have said so in my End of Life documents.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report

No you don't. You just have to abide by state laws on how to dispose of a body according to that's states rules and regulations. Funerals are expensive and can be as complicated/simple as the person who's dead wishes them to be. Work with your loved one to find out what and how they want in terms of burial/cremation etc. and if they want a funeral.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Jhalldenton
Report

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter