Follow
Share
Read More
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
1 2 3
How do you get him to see.... you let him fo it for a day. If he refuses that tells you all you need to know.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

Here is what I think your problem is with your husband. He simply does NOT want them there. Happened with my ex. His father was deceased and MIL was in 80's and her house was condemned. I told me husband that I would be glad to have her move in with us and would help take care of her. I know now, that I would have done everything as you are doing while he would be angry. Also, we lived in Colorado at the time and MIL gets severe altitude sickness. I offered to move to wherever (stay at home mom), even back to where she was comfortable, around other family members in Oklahoma. He would not discuss it. He had actually moved AWAY from Oklahoma years before to get away from at least some of his family, most likely parents.

So.. I take it that the idea for his parents to move in with you and hubby was YOUR idea? And he did not say no? Well... he does not want them there so.....put them somewhere else since that is the case. Like my now ex.... (yay) he clearly wants nothing to do with his parents. Sad.

Also.... your husband, like most people, have NEVER done caregiving. It is difficult. Demanding. Time consuming. And so much more. I have been a home health aide for almost 30 years so I know. Your hubby won't understand until he actually gets in there and does NOT some of it... but most of it himself then he might change his tune. My ex is NOT a caregiver. He hates caregiving. He is afraid of people spending his money. That could be an issue with your hubby? It can take a LOT of money to take care of someone... extras that you don't normally have on hand--- the elderly many times are incontinent so how to deal with that? Many get to the point they cannot dress, bathe, feed themselves, wipe themselves, turn themselves in bed and when people are bedbound, they need to be turned at least every 2 hours to prevent bedsores. Bedsores.... another potential problem. Many cannot stand so the caregiver has to be the one to "get them up"... "move them around" and some of these people are obese. They have to have assistance with everything usually at some point and it is physically demanding... (so much more than demanding) my back aches from the years of doing this. I am 67.

No one is offering to help. If they wanted to help they would be doing it. So... put them somewhere else. It is ONLY going to get much worse and then when that happens, trying to move them to somewhere is going to be a huge challenge. Please... do it NOW.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

I take care of a woman. Her husband.... like a helicopter parent. I have never seen anything like this. He is now trying to do the cooking. She can't stand on her own. He has to ask her how to cook whatever she has ordered for that particular meal. They are in their 80's. He dotes on her.... well.... it is even more than that! Doting? Good grief. She insists on using certain glasses and they are small so we end up having to constantly refill them. Again, I work for an agency as one of her caregivers. He has dementia. She does also but not quite as severe. He is constantly "at her" for something... wanting to know if she needs anything. She treats him like crap. And us, too! She orders this man around.... and us, too. When we put her to bed, she then goes through this..... she is talking, "OK... pull me a little towards you. OK... now go around to the other side, and pull me a little that way. Ok.. now go around to the other side and pull me a little that way. Ok... now go around to the other side and pull me a little that way." This goes on 9-12 times, running around from one side of her bed to the other..... every night. She keeps her hubby hopping. And when things are NOT done exactly right, he is always apologizing. Even to us! He wants to make meals for us.... her caregivers and I keep telling him, "... OK.. I am not your wife. You don't take care of me. I am here to take care of your wife". And another thing... she was demanding that we take care of her hubby... do things for him even though she is our patient/client. I told her we could not do that and she said, "That is ridiculous and that you are to do whatever you can to help us." Manipulation! Guilt trips. I did not fall for that. I told her... no... I will not give him his eye drops. He is not our patient. Only your name is on the documentation. (I watched him.... he can do it himself)

These pics on television of the elderly, smiling... acting so sweet... being served salads in this gorgeous home...not true a great majority of the time. THAT is not reality. Most of my patients cannot walk.... all have dementia. And they certainly do NOT eat salads. Most eat soft foods. Most are obese. Most cannot even turn themself in bed. Most cannot hold a conversation. Most are incontinent and we have to bathe them and wipe their butts.

Also.... people will tell you all the time that so and so does "it" so you should be doing it too! They also will fire their housekeepers and then hire us not ONLY for taking care of one or two patients BUT... to clean the whole house and keep it that way. I tell them we are caregivers and not housekeepers. And yep.. they get angry. We make around $10 an hour or less. Also... try telling a housekeeper some time that you expect them to start assisting you to the toilet and wiping your butt.... and helping you get dressed... and into bed...and make your meals while they are there.

Your hubby does NOT want anything to do with his parents at least while they are in your home. Things are NOT going to change. He resents them being there. He is going to do his own thing as if they are NOT there. This is the way my ex is towards his parents. Wanted nothing to do with them. When MIL needed money, my husband would NOT talk about it and he gave his mom nothing. Nada. He would NEVER call her. When she showed up unexpectedly at our house, dropped off by other family members I had never met....LOL..... I could tell hubby was NOT happy. He obviously did NOT want her there. The poor woman got severe altitude sickness and I was the one to deal with it while also taking care of our twins, age 1 1/2 years. But then, I am a professional caregiver, right? LOL My ex... not really a family man. He would not help with the kids, either. When he was not driving his truck, he was OFF work. He used to say, "What do you do all day?" He thinks he knows that a stay at home mom is an easy, peasy job but I know he could never do what I do.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report
LittleOrchid Feb 2021
ROFL. Tell us like it is! I loved this vent, and a peek at the role of an professional caregiver. If I ever need an in-home caregiver, I would love to hire you. Aging is not sweet, and whoever called them the golden years was totally disconnected from the day-to-day reality of sinking in to the senescence. There are some good years in what I think of as "young old-age." It goes downhill from there. At 70, we are "young old-age" the 80's are "middle old-age" and the 90's are just plain old, old, old. We are having a good time, enjoying what remains of our health, and trying to get the mindset that we will, above all else, try to keep our sense of humor as we approach those middle years.
(2)
Report
Frustrated45, you don't have to live this way! Trust me, I know, because I was in the same position. Even if you initially agreed to take care of them when they moved in, guess what? You can change your mind and lay down new boundaries! You have to do this now, even if it will trigger arguments with your husband, otherwise, your life will be miserable until the inlaws pass away. YOU DESERVE BETTER. My in-laws live with us, as does my own mom who has dementia. The in-laws are mentally intact but physically decrepit. My MiL is addicted to sleeping pills, then she got COVID (without ever having left the house between March-Oct. 2020). Since then her heart rate has been difficult to manage and she falls regularly in the middle of the night because she is taking sleeping pills against her doctor's advice. For the first 8 months, they would ask me to do absolutely everything (including picking her up off the floor). They wanted to avoid asking their son (my husband) because he snaps at them and says he's too busy. That's his Modus Operandi--react unpleasantly so nobody bothers you. It all came to a head last summer when she got upset with me for something minor. I told them I regretted allowing them to move in and I demanded that they move out. I put them in touch with a Medicaid application assistant. They found out they can't even afford the minimum contribution for subsidized assisted living but they aren't sick enough to qualify for a Medicaid-paid nursing home. So I am stuck with them. The first thing I did was lay down the new laws. 1. Every task that you can physically do yourself, you must do, even if you'd rather not. (Loading and emptying the dishwasher, clearing the table, sweeping up messes that they make, putting clothes away, toilet plunging). 2. Your son (my husband) is the FIRST person you ask when you need anything: rides to an doctor's appointments, special requests from the grocery story, diet coke (they're both addicts), something off a high shelf, etc. 3. I am your helper of last resort. I have my own mother to care for and I work from home. Frustrated45, it's all about getting up the nerve to set boundaries. Also, since your husband has siblings, you could suggest they pool their money to pay for an aide to be in the house for 20 hours a week. Wishing you strength in sticking up for yourself!
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Set healthy boundaries and make a list for every member of the family to contribute. Explain calmly, politely and firmly that they are not your parents but their so it is their responsibility to pick up slack and give you time for yourself.

If they refuse perhaps it is time for you to take a little vacation alone and let them experience what you go through. Inform them you will come back when there is a written contract on who does what.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

It seems perhaps your husband is in denial. Perhaps he doesn’t want to face what his parents are now going through. There getting older and he is now responsible for them. Maybe he just doesn’t want to face that? You need to get his sisters involved and let them know you can’t do this alone especially if your husband is not being understanding. Goodness, he’s acting like this now, how is he going to act when they actually become sick?? You have your life to live too! There needs to be a balance because caring for elderly parents is very frustrating and demanding and if you don’t have help IT WON’T WORK! His sisters need to come help at least one weekend a month and alternate, it’s only fair everyone contributes, plus it’s their parents! Sisters need to understand that after they have their weekend, once or twice a month they get to leave and go home. You don’t!! I don’t know about your in laws financials, but in ADDITION, THEIR money needs to be used to hire caregivers to help both of you get through this, if you don’t get help not only will your relationship w/ your husband suffer but so will your health. Lastly, perhaps your husband needs to see someone to help him get over his fears of what’s happening with his parents and this entire situation. His parents also should start seeing a Geriatric Dr., who specializes in aging people and this dr., is more flexible w/meds and dosages as their individual needs change for the rest of their life. Oh and if sisters live out of state etc., then they need to send money to help hire caregivers to take their place. Good Luck and God Bless.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

You appear to be suffering from being too good at everything. People let you do everything because they (and you) know you will do it better than they might. You have every right to be feeling the stress of this situation. You also have a tiny bit of blame for it. Your in-laws expect you to do everything for them because they know you will. You are probably a high energy person who loves to stay busy. Surprise! there is a point where even you can't keep up anymore. I agree with others that it is time for you to put yourself first. It may also be time for a little tough love for your husband and his parents. Don't hang up the phone for them. Don't look up the numbers for them. Tell them the book is right next to the phone.

Take that weekend off, and take part of it too make a list of things that you will not do for others. Practice saying polite versions of "do it yourself." You will need to practice because I doubt very much that you have said it very much.

You sound very much like one of my sisters, who always got stuck with more than her share of work simply because she was good at it and did it quickly. She still is and does and sometimes she is bitter about the whole thing. We all love her dearly, and we do help, but if she didn't hop right in there and get working right away the world would not come to an end. Practice sitting at the table enjoying your coffee for a while before you jump up and get at the dishes. Maybe smile sweetly and suggest that it may be your husband's turn to do the dishes. I raised my kids with this: "there is too much work in this world for anyone to get a free ride." You have made life too easy for your husband, his sisters, and his parents. Time to make them take their share of the work.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report

Lots of advise, I have not read all the way thru. My first thought, when they ask you for something, direct them to ask their son..... maybe if they place more than necessary things on his shoulders, he will stand up.....
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

Let him do it. Stop being a doormat.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

First of all, I understand completely your anger and frustration and disgust with your husband - I'd be the first to join you in that. I am guessing but I wonder if dementia and the usual aging problems are setting in now that they have a "maid" (you)....or is it just for their convenience because they are lazy. I don't know but perhaps a doctor could give some insight. I am horrified and sickened by your husband's reaction - that is horrible. Is he filled with guilt as he really does "see" what is going on but can't help himself or doesn't want to and doesn't know what to do? Or is he just a lousy, selfish, demanding husband? Only you can answer that but there is NO way I would accept this behavior from them (unless there was a dam good reason), nor from him. He should be supporting you. Sit him down and calmly state your case. If he starts yelling at you and not listening, just get up after telling him that as of this very moment, he is on his own with his parents. YOU are not lifting another finger in any way - and stick to that. Tell him to take care of them or find someone as a caretaker or place them but you have had enough - it has ended. Then disappear by doing something special for you, treat yourself to something special, etc.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

I can totally relate to your situation in so many ways it’s unbelievable.
If I could relay one piece of advice, it’s to take as many caregiver breaks as possible until they move to a nearby facility. I had to put my foot down finally in my life even if I was sick. The sooner the better.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Are you financially independent? How far you can enforce your boundaries may ultimately depend on that.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

Your situation reminds me a bit of my husband. We had a colicky newborn who cried incessantly from 3-10p.m. every single day for five months. My husband worked long hours, which included a fair amount of traveling, and when he came home, he understandably wanted a decent dinner waiting for him at the very least.

One day when he came home to find me frantically rocking the screaming baby and no dinner ever started, he finally said, "What do you DO all day??" so I decided to write it down.

The next day I kept a pad of paper with me all day, and I wrote down every single thing I did. He left for work at 6 a.m. and the baby woke up shortly after that, so I did, too. (I'd been up at 3:30 a.m. to feed her for an hour, too.) I kept track of everything I did -- and at what time to the minute I did it. I kept track from 6:30 until 3 p.m. when the colic would kick in, because we both knew nothing got done from that point on.

I discovered I didn't do one single task that lasted longer than 2-3 minutes without some kind of interruption, and that included eating, showering, and going to the bathroom. I presented that lengthy list of 8 1/2 hours of doing "nothing" to my husband, and he never brought it up again.

Over the years of raising three children with a husband who traveled much of the time, I learned to turn a deaf ear to the annoying comments -- like the one when he called from a lengthy business trip and said, "I am SO sick of lobster!" while we were eating Kraft macaroni for the third night in a row -- but the main thing is I made sure he understood that I was not a martyr and the job was not easy. I started venting in a journal, but I did tell him all the things I'd done in a day just to keep him up to speed on my lazy ways. ;-)

I suggest you, too, vent in a journal, but let your husband know EVERYTHING you do in a day, and let him know as well when (not if) you'll be taking days off to do things on your own.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report

Another thought about Valentine’s Day. If DH thinks that you could take the day off from his parents to come and take photos of him, it probably shows that he has no idea at all about what they are demanding from you every day. Perhaps it also shows that he wants to spend more time with you having fun away from the parents. It might even be possible that he had planned a swim and nice lunch for both of you. If he suggests this again, it might be good to go along with it, and see how it plays out. It could be an easier alternative than you walking out for the day. At the very least, it creates a need for his parents to fend for themselves for a day.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

You are right to be bothered. My wife took wonderful care of my father, who was also an angel in his last years. I helped whenever a direct work conflict did not get in the way. I wonder if he is mad at his sisters. Anyway he is being both selfish and lazy in these last years. He needs to carry his load without galivanting off to his "play time" unless you get to be with him. No excuses for him. Start hiring home help and reserving time away for yourself. Do not ask for permission or forgiveness. You are carrying the load so he has no say in the matter except one of appreciation and hopefully participation. Your husband seems to think you are a doormat (at least some of the time).
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Go away for a long weekend with your friends and leave him in charge of his parents.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

When you go away for a long 3 day weekend (which you should do for your piece of mind), they may be wonderful with "their" son so be prepared. You may want to get a camera and place it so your husband can see what is going on. You can say you got it for security reasons so you could leave and still be able to check on them.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

I would tell him that you have plans away from the home to do an activity you choose to do and he is in charge. Leave some notes. When it is time to have him take over, remind him of your plans, and then leave for the day. He will have a new appreciation for what you do. These are his parents and his primary responsibility. He needs to step up. Plan more days off of caretaking duty if he needs more experience.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
Oskigirl Feb 2021
Agreed, but I would do it for more than just one day as he can push off anything unpleasant for a day. Leave for a few days. A week. Whatever.
(3)
Report
Imho, tell him to take care of his parents.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

I am going through the same thing in caring for my mother in law. My husband bought his mom a beautiful home designed especially for seniors. She has dementia and doesn't even need to live alone. She moved in with us 9 weeks after falling and breaking her hip. She had used up her rehab days and the nursing home said at 93 she didn't qualify for permanent residency there. But, she should have been walking but she refused to get up. The real clincher was that I had just had a total hip replacement 13 days before she moved in!!!!! So I was taking care of her, carrying her meals to her and cleaning her when she souled the bed. I had no help. He continued to work and when he came home he didn't help either. My two grown children never once came so I could get out and go grocery shopping. I was a trapped lion!! Now, a year later she went back home, now falling and breaking three ribs. I have to go there at least once a day to set up her pills and keep the house clean. She is writing checks to every person who asks for a donation. Last month 2 checks totalling $175.00 was sent to some animal rescue and she is buying candy and junk from publishers clearing house cause she thinks they are going to give her a job and pay her $5,000.00 a week. I have to get there when the mail runs to destroy all the letters wanting donations. I get no break, and when I tell him what she is doing he gets mad at me for telling him!!!!! I am up to my neck with this, but I have her home health company looking for a placement in a home. Its all fine and good to transfer responsibility to your spouse but is it fair??? Its like "out of sight out of mind". I am not healthy, and what will he do when I can no longer take care of her? I live in fear she will fall and lay there till i go in the house or she will wander outside. We can't afford around the clock sitters or even night time sitters. We are spending more and more of our money for her while she gives it away, but if I mention it, my husband gets mad. I hope you can find help, but in fact there are more and more family members having to care for the elderly. We planned to retire next year and travel, but that's not gonna happen. I had to retire from nursing after 31 yrs because of severe arthritis. I have had multiple back surgeries which have me at least walking good, but I risk messing all that up. Maybe things will get better for you, and I pray they do.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
Oskigirl Feb 2021
Have him take care of her. You need to take care of yourself. If he's too selfish, spend some time at your kids' house.
(3)
Report
See 3 more replies
Tell him you're leaving for a weekend, 4 days, whatever, to visit a close friend or relative who needs your help. (I know it's tough in times of COVID, but do what you can while staying safe). Then see how he does when he has to care for them alone. He's being manipulative to turn it into a situation where they have to move because of you. Or why don't his sisters pitch in?
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

I would tell him that you have been working full time taking care of his parents and that everyone is entitled to have a few days off and that yours is starting tomorrow.  Pack a bag, get in the care and go somewhere.  Go visit family or friends or just go to a nice hotel and read a book.  Leave him to care for his own parents.  Let him know that since he didn't plan anything for valentines day you planned your own.

He's got it made in the shade....his parents are right there and taken care of and his wife puts a hot meal on the table every night.  His world is perfect.  Yours however is not.  I don't know why you agreed to this arrangement, but you need to tell him you have misjudged the situation and have changed your mind.

Just curious...why didn't one of your sister in laws take them in?
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Two things:

1. Marriage counseling.

2. Leave him home alone with them for a week or a long weekend.

Try both!
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Go on strike. That's what my SIL did. Before I became a part of the family, my SIL was primary caregiver to our MIL. She was always so patient unlike her sons. While the strike was ongoing, the three sons took turns doing things for her (dr. appts, grocery shopping etc.) It was actually funny, the three of them were terror stricken at SIL's strike. My SIL did go back and take on some of the duties, but the sons still had their turns. My husband ultimately appreciated SIL's strike and told her so after MIL died.

Unlike you though MIL had her own home. You'd have to go on vacation and leave your husband with his parents for a few days. Ideally he and his siblings "walk in your shoes".

If any of his other sibling aren't willing to take in their parents, then they should be aiding you. Does your husband feel guilty? Or did he decide this is to be your life's work? When he gets home, does he take on some of the duties/errands his parents ask of you?

Is there any way the two of you can sit and have an Honest, Quiet discussion. Say go out for nice dinner, just the two of you, then when emotions are calmer, talk. Together, set boundaries with his parents (rules of the house) and if you are busy they learn to wait patiently. Set up shared duties - what you do, what hubby does, what his siblings do. Would hiring a care giver a few hours a couple days a week be doable so you get time to yourself all by yourself or you and your husband together. If your husband is just dumping his parents off on you, then yes other living arrangements should be made.

When it was getting that MIL was no longer able to live on her own and discussions were going on within the family, I offered to my husband that we could move into her house - which was not the most realistic offer but I was willing to give it a try.

And I've previously posted that living with my father would have sent me to be committed and my mother living with my husband would also end up with her being committed. Not everyone can do in home care of their LOs. Good Luck
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Maybe he should take over the duties? For a little taste of the excitement?
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Is English your first language or from what culture are you originally? I'm asking because your wrote a non-American phrase, "I'm curious as to why he is not superbly grateful." Superbly grateful." is a common google translate phrase for a region across the globe in a culture, that expects women to be subservient to everything male.
Thus far everyone commenting has been assuming that you're 100% from and within a typical Western culture. I'm thinking that you're from Dubai, living in the states, but still tied to a very restrictive culture, that carries enormous wealth, and penalties for non-compliance.
I'll need more cultural background b/4 answering, because expecting anyone to be "superbly grateful," is one of many cultural differences that might be happening,
Based on the wording minimally he originates from wealth, which might be his uper hand so-to-speak. Your background seems to be from a place, that requires catering to in-laws, if you fail to do so, you'll be penalized? It's a guess, but I'm familiar with it So the only thing that seems obvious is that his country club perspective expects women to be a perfectly compliant "secretary, cook, housekeeper, chauffeur, therapist, and social committee all at once." Whilst understandably, you don't like being declassified and disrespected, as an overworked member of "the help."
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Is it possible that you are living in a culture where the son is responsible for parents, meaning son's wife will be doing the work? If so, might explain hubby's anger. The other possibility is what you said - he would have said no, but you welcomed them (so now he will look like the bad son if he asks them to leave).

He needs to be a little more involved because they are his parents (unless, of course, the wife is expected to do all of this from a cultural point of view). When hubby is in the room and they ask for something to be retrieved, get yourself out of the area and holler back at hubby - could you help your mom, please? I'm working on this or that. What does he do to participate in your household? The online shopping, banking, etc? He can do those things for them. --- Could you help your mom find a new watch online and order it for her?

When they ask you to do something for them that you know they can do, get them more involved in their own care. From their perspective. You used to take care of this yourself, if you stop doing little things you used to do, you will not be able to do them. Same as sitting in chair too long, the longer you sit, the less you will be able to do tomorrow. I want to see you both keep moving around, keeping your mind active, doing what you can so we can all continue to help each other. If either of you or both of you don't stay active, it may reach a point where I can't physically take care of you.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

The first mistake of course was letting them move in but that is water under the bridge.

I would list some benchmarks in areas they need to change or they will get booted out to a living situation that is equipped to handle this.

I have found hard enough to care for my own mom, I would not want to be burdened like you are with a MIL
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Easy. You do less. Their son does more. Take a holiday for a couple of days. The rapid change in his attitude will be amazing and move them up to assisted living
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

The first mistake of course was letting them move in but that is water under the bridge.

I would list some benchmarks in areas they need to change or they will get booted out to a living situation that is equipped to handle this.

I have found hard enough to care for my own mom, I would not want to be burdened like you are with a MIL
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

1 2 3
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter